This activity is completed in a College Composition II course. Students in this class must complete College Composition I, a basic essay writing course, before enrolling in this research-based, argumentative writing course. Class size is typically about 25 students, but the activity could work for smaller or larger classes as well.
This paper is assigned after students have had some exposure and in-class practice of paraphrasing and peer review. I usually schedule parts of three class sessions to complete the paper.
Class# 1: I handout out the assignment sheet and the essay being paraphrased. I use an essay that focuses on an aspect of education relatable to college learners, giving the students a discussion point as they work with their group members. Students are encouraged to form groups of three on their own, but I will help with group formation if needed.
Class #2: Students bring in the rough draft of their paraphrase. I discuss the importance of peer review and receiving feedback from others. I also give the scoring rubric sheet to the groups, so students can see what my expectations are for the final product. The students are then given the rest of the classtime to review each of their group members' paragraphs, using the peer review sheet.
The students then have one week outside of class to revise their paragraphs, and through email, assemble the three paragraphs into one group paper.
Class #3: One week after in-class peer review, I collect the final paper of each group, along with the individual rough drafts and peer reviews. I grade the papers and provide feedback to the groups within one week after the final paper is due. Students are also asked to fill out an individual reflection sheet to include with their final paper.
Files included are: 1. The assignment sheet. 2. A power point I use for the "rules" of peer review 3. The peer review sheet 4. The score sheet for the final product. 5. The individual reflection sheet.
- Handout for Group Paraphrasing Assignment(Rich Text File 49kB Feb17 10)
- Peer Review Rules(PowerPoint 99kB Jan25 10)
- Peer Review Sheet(Rich Text File 31kB Jan25 10)
- Score Sheet(Rich Text File 32kB Jan25 10)
- Reflection sheet for Group Paraphrase Paper(Rich Text File 37kB Feb17 10)
Besides filling out the rubric score sheet for the students, I provide each group with a typed paragraph of comments written specifically for their paper, as well as comments on the paper itself. The comments point out what was done well and what needs improvement for the future.
References and Resources
See more Teaching Activities »
Может быть, для того, чтобы вы не заподозрили, что это приманка. Может быть, Танкадо защитил его ровно настолько, чтобы вы на него наткнулись и сочли, что вам очень повезло. Это придает правдоподобность его электронной переписке. - Тебе следовало бы работать в полиции, - улыбнулся Стратмор. - Идея неплохая, но на каждое послание Танкадо, увы, поступает ответ.