Critical Thinking Rubric Aacu High Impact

On By In 1
  • Civic Learning in the Major by Design

    Fall 2017

    Educating students to be responsible, informed, and engaged citizens in their workplaces and the... Read more

  • Faculty Collaboratives

    Summer 2017

    This issue features the AAC&U Faculty Collaboratives project, which has created a large-scale,... Read more

  • Committing to Equity and Inclusive Excellence

    Spring 2017

    Since 1970, bachelor degree attainment among students from wealthy families nearly doubled, but it... Read more

  • New Frontiers in Writing

    Winter 2017

    This issue builds on and explores implications of findings from the National Census of Writing. It... Read more

  • Integrating Evidence: The STIRS Approach

    Fall 2016

    The Scientific Thinking and Integrative Reasoning Skills (STIRS) framework has been developed, used... Read more

  • Advancing Equity and Student Success through Eportfolios

    Summer 2016

    Adoption of eportfolio pedagogies and practices in conjunction with Signature Work provide the... Read more

  • Transparency and Problem-Centered Learning

    Winter/Spring 2016

    This issue, funded by TG Philanthropy, explores the relationship between high-impact practices and... Read more

  • Advancing Collaborative Roadmaps for Student Success

    Fall 2015

    Sponsored by The Kresge Foundation, this issue focuses on campus, state, regional, and national... Read more

  • Rethinking Preparation for Work: A Civic-Enriched Liberal Education

    Summer 2015

    In a world where college graduates spend the majority of their public lives engaged in work, this... Read more

  • Navigating Institutional Change for Student Success in STEM

    Spring 2015

    This issue, sponsored by the W. M. Keck Foundation as part of the PKAL Guide to Systemic... Read more

  • Faculty Leadership for Integrative Liberal Learning

    Fall/Winter 2015

    This issue, sponsored by the Teagle and Mellon foundations, offers insights about the central role... Read more

  • Quantitative Reasoning

    Summer 2014

    Quantitative reasoning skills―the habit of mind, competency, and comfort in working with numerical... Read more

  • Gender Equity in STEM

    Spring 2014

    Close examination of the status of women science and engineering faculty at four-year colleges and... Read more

  • E-Portfolios: For Reflection, Learning, and Assessment

    Winter 2014

    E-portfolios are now being used in more than half of US colleges and universities. This issue... Read more

  • Capstones and Integrative Learning

    Fall 2013

    Whether they’re called senior capstones or some other name, these culminating experiences require... Read more

  • The Changing Nature of Faculty Roles

    Summer 2013

    This issue explores the evolution of faculty roles, including the growing dependence on non-tenure-... Read more

  • Models for Student Success: Developing a Community College Student Roadmap

    Spring 2013

    This issue highlights lessons learned from Developing a Community College Student Roadmap, the LEAP... Read more

  • Collaborative Leadership for Liberal Education

    Winter 2013

    This issue explores how campus leaders—presidents, boards, administrators and faculty—can best work... Read more

  • Essential Learning Outcomes, the New MCAT, and Curricular Change

    Fall 2012

    This issue focuses on the new changes to the MCAT, which focus more on broad integrative learning... Read more

  • Frontiers of Faculty Work: Embracing Innovation and High-Impact Practices

    Summer 2012

    This issue centers on how faculty are using high-impact educational practices in individual... Read more

  • The Liberally Educated Professional

    Spring 2012

    This issue explores how various professional programs, such as education, engineering, and nursing... Read more

  • Assessing Liberal Education Outcomes Using VALUE Rubrics

    Fall/Winter 2011

    This issue focuses on AAC&U’s VALUE rubrics, which were tested on more than one hundred pilot... Read more

  • Advancing What Works in STEM: A View Through the PKAL Lens

    Summer 2011

    This issue of Peer Review emerges from the new partnership between Project Kaleidoscope (PKAL) and... Read more

  • Lessons on Systemic Reform from the LEAP States Initiative

    Spring 2011

    This issue of Peer Review highlights lessons learned from AAC&U’s LEAP States initiative.... Read more

  • Returning Adult Students

    Winter 2011

    Adult students comprise a growing population on college campuses. This issue features a range of... Read more

  • Internships and Experiential Learning

    Fall 2010

    Articles in this issue present best practices for creating internships and other experiential... Read more

  • The Future of the Faculty: Collaborating to Cultivate Change

    Summer 2010

    This issue explores new strategies for diversifying the faculty and developing their effectiveness... Read more

  • Undergraduate Research

    Spring 2010

    This issue highlights undergraduate programs that integrate students into the research community... Read more

  • Engaging Departments: Assessing Student Learning

    Winter 2010

    This issue explores how departments are developing assessment approaches that deepen student... Read more

  • Study Abroad and Global Learning: Exploring Connections

    Fall 2009

    Peer Review, Fall, 2009: Features articles on best practices in campus study abroad programs,... Read more

  • Liberal Education and Undergraduate Public Health Studies

    Summer 2009

    This issue makes the case for a bridge between the undergraduate and public health communities,... Read more

  • Good Teaching: What Is It and How Do We Measure It?

    Spring 2009

    This issue addresses specific challenges faculty are facing in the classroom today. It explores... Read more

  • Assessing Learning Outcomes: Lessons from AAC&U's VALUE Project

    Winter 2009

    This issue focuses on AAC&U’s VALUE project and provides an overview of new assessment... Read more

  • Toward Intentionality and Integration

    Fall 2008

    Intentionality and integrative learning, captured in the LEAP vision of essential learning outcomes... Read more

  • Student Political Engagement

    Spring/Summer 2008

    This issue examines how the academy engages students in their learning today to help them grow as... Read more

  • Academic Advising

    Winter 2008

    This issue addresses the role of academic advising in undergraduate education with a special focus... Read more

  • Faculty Development: Finding Balance in Changing Roles

    Fall 2007

    Faculty development will play a critical role in efforts to achieve essential learning outcomes for... Read more

  • Bringing Theory to Practice

    Summer 2007

    The Bringing Theory to Practice (BTtoP) project seeks to advance engaged student learning and... Read more

  • Assessing Student Learning

    Spring 2007

    As campuses implement more complex assignments, community placements, internships, student research... Read more

  • Student Preparation, Motivation, and Achievement

    Winter 2007

    The issue presents data on college readiness, effective strategies for increasing student... Read more

  • Learning & Technology

    Fall 2006

    This issue examines a range of current issues concerning the role and use of technology in student... Read more

  • Successful Transitions to College Through First- Year Programs

    Summer 2006

    This issue features first-year programs that are designed to facilitate positive transitions for... Read more

  • The Creativity Imperative

    Spring 2006

    Why is cultivating creative abilities among today’s students so essential? This issue focuses on... Read more

  • Undergraduate Research

    Winter 2006

    This issue highlights undergraduate programs that integrate students into the research community... Read more

  • Integrative Learning

    Summer/Fall 2005

    The Summer/Fall 2005 issue of Peer Review focuses on integrative learning. Integrative abilities... Read more

  • Liberal Education and the Entrepreneurial Spirit

    Spring 2005

    Sponsored by the Kauffman Consortium for Liberal Education and Entrepreneurship, housed at the... Read more

  • Science and Engaged Learning

    Winter 2005

    This issue explores efforts to improve science education for majors and nonmajors through new forms... Read more

  • Creating Shared Responsibility for General Education and Assessment

    Fall 2004

    Challenging the widespread notion that general education is something to "get out of the way as... Read more

  • Quantitative Literacy

    Summer 2004

    This issue focuses on quantitative literacy as a key outcome of liberal education and explores... Read more

  • Advancing the Conversation Between Graduate and Undergraduate Education

    Spring 2004

    Planned in coordination with the Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching, this issue... Read more

  • (R)Evolution of the New Globally Engaged Academy

    Winter 2004

    This issue focuses on the evolving identities and missions of colleges and universities as they... Read more

  • Writing and the New Academy

    Fall 2003

    This issue focuses on writing as a key outcome of liberal education and explores recent trends in... Read more

  • General Education in the New Academy

    Summer 2003

    This issue addresses new models for general education with a focus on models of integrative... Read more

  • Educating for Citizenship

    Spring 2003

    This issue focuses on how the academic goals of liberal education are enhanced by civic engagement... Read more

  • Purposeful Pathways? A Look at School-College Alignment

    Winter 2003

    This issue provides a critical overview of school-college alignment efforts and makes the case for... Read more

  • Contingent Faculty and Student Learning

    Fall 2002

    This issue explores issues and trends associated with the use of part-time and full-time non-tenure... Read more

  • The Values Question in Higher Education

    Summer 2002

    This issue explores the ways colleges and universities are addressing the values questions today's... Read more

  • Value Added Assessment of Liberal Education

    Winter/Spring 2002

    This issue presents the RAND Corporation/Council for Aid to Education's Value Added Assessment... Read more

  • Learning Communities: A Sustainable Innovation?

  • The VALUE rubrics were developed by teams of faculty experts representing colleges and universities across the United States through a process that examined many existing campus rubrics and related documents for each learning outcome and incorporated additional feedback from faculty. The rubrics articulate fundamental criteria for each learning outcome, with performance descriptors demonstrating progressively more sophisticated levels of attainment. The rubrics are intended for institutional-level use in evaluating and discussing student learning, not for grading. The core expectations articulated in all 16 of the VALUE rubrics can and should be translated into the language of individual campuses, disciplines, and even courses. The utility of the VALUE rubrics is to position learning at all undergraduate levels within a basic framework of expectations such that evidence of learning can by shared nationally through a common dialog and understanding of student success.

    Preview the Critical Thinking VALUE Rubric: click to expand

    Download the Critical Thinking VALUE Rubric at no cost via AAC&U's Shopping Cart (links below):

    Definition

    Critical thinking is a habit of mind characterized by the comprehensive exploration of issues, ideas, artifacts, and events before accepting or formulating an opinion or conclusion.

    Framing Language

    This rubric is designed to be transdisciplinary, reflecting the recognition that success in all disciplines requires habits of inquiry and analysis that share common attributes. Further, research suggests that successful critical thinkers from all disciplines increasingly need to be able to apply those habits in various and changing situations encountered in all walks of life.

    This rubric is designed for use with many different types of assignments and the suggestions here are not an exhaustive list of possibilities. Critical thinking can be demonstrated in assignments that require students to complete analyses of text, data, or issues. Assignments that cut across presentation mode might be especially useful in some fields. If insight into the process components of critical thinking (e.g., how information sources were evaluated regardless of whether they were included in the product) is important, assignments focused on student reflection might be especially illuminating.

    Glossary

    The definitions that follow were developed to clarify terms and concepts used in this rubric only.

    • Ambiguity: Information that may be interpreted in more than one way.
    • Assumptions: Ideas, conditions, or beliefs (often implicit or unstated) that are "taken for granted or accepted as true without proof." (quoted from www.dictionary.reference.com/browse/assumptions)
    • Context: The historical, ethical. political, cultural, environmental, or circumstantial settings or conditions that influence and complicate the consideration of any issues, ideas, artifacts, and events.
    • Literal meaning: Interpretation of information exactly as stated. For example, "she was green with envy" would be interpreted to mean that her skin was green.
    • Metaphor: Information that is (intended to be) interpreted in a non-literal way. For example, "she was green with envy" is intended to convey an intensity of emotion, not a skin color.

    Acceptable Use and Reprint Permissions

    For information on how to reference and cite the VALUE rubrics, visit: How to Cite the VALUE Rubrics.

    Individuals are welcome to reproduce the VALUE rubrics for use in the classroom, on educational web sites, and in campus intra-institutional publications. A permission fee will be assessed for requests to reprint the rubrics in course packets or in other copyrighted print or electronic publications intended for sale. Please see AAC&U's permission policies for more details and information about how to request permission.

    VALUE rubrics can also be used in commercial databases, software, or assessment products, but prior permission from AAC&U is required. For all uses of rubrics for commercial purposes, each rubric must be maintained in its entirety and without changes.

    0 comments

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *